Chat


How can I help you?

Explain project
Write a project description
Find schematic issues

Backup Charge Qualification Decision
Decision — 2026-10-22
Charging deferred. No qualified integrated pack/charger solution was established within the bounded research. Retain GlobTek BL2200F9031781S1PCKT as the conditional procurement concept, not as an approved charging combination. Do not change charger or substitute a pack on the strength of this report. Continue unrelated PCB engineering with optional backup absent and charging positively inhibited. This is an engineering evidence gap, not a request for an owner waiver.
Read first: current Project Specification and Backup Battery Recommendation. No schematic, layout, or writer-owned specification was changed. This separate project file is the research handoff.
Existing candidate — facts reused from Backup Battery Recommendation
  • Protected 1S 2.2 Ah, nominal 3.7 V; maximum continuous discharge 2.2 A gives 0.7 A nominal headroom above the requested 1.5 A peak. Cold/aged impedance and complete path performance are untested. Prior evidence handle: dsq_57cf769592e605991374.
  • Manufacturer charge specification: maximum 4.2 V, recommended 4.1 V ±1%, standard 0.6 A, maximum 1.5 A. The existing fixed-4.2-V BQ24075 combination remains unapproved; its worst-case regulation cannot be justified merely by a nominal maximum.
  • Prior verified pinout: 1 red P+, 2 white NTC, 3 black P−; JST PHR-3 housing or equal, 60 ±5 mm three-conductor harness. Confirm supplied revision and physical numbered orientation before mating; wire colours alone are not proof.
  • Prior mechanical drawing: 78 ×31 mm, thickness 8.8 ±0.5 mm but also described as maximum 8.8 mm. Reserve at least the tolerance envelope plus manufacturer-required swelling/strain relief; resolve contradictory thickness wording before mechanical freeze.
  • Prior operating limits: charge 0–45°C, discharge −20–60°C. Discharge cutoff recommendation 3.0 V; pack-protector undervoltage trip is not a normal operating target. These reused values are recorded with original citations in the existing Backup Battery Recommendation; this report does not claim a new independent verification of every reused fact.
New targeted datasheet check
The supplied GlobTek document identifies the thermistor only as 10K, with no reference temperature or resistance tolerance in that entry. Exact thermistor MPN, reference R–T table or coefficients, beta and its reference temperatures/tolerance, resistance tolerance, and pack thermal coupling/lag remain unverified. No resistor calculation is authorized from a generic “10k NTC.”
The documented storage/charge-retention conditions are less than one year at −20 to +20°C and less than three months at −20 to +45°C, with >80% retention. These are not permission for indefinite hot-cabin storage. The selected pack's allowable longer-term parked-cabin service/standby-charge policy remains unverified.
Procurement evidence
Prior DigiKey snapshot (2026-10-20): 1939-BL2200F9031781S1PCKT-ND, 339 available, USD16.52 quantity one. Not refreshed, reserved, or purchased in this task. No currently qualified replacement or new charger stock is claimed. Battery is separately sourced, not a JLCPCB placement item.
Bounded alternative-family screening
At most two alternative vendor families were searched: RRC standard packs and Inspired Energy smart packs. Neither established the specified three-wire analog-NTC replacement.
  1. RRC1120 is credible electrically: current datasheet gives 3.60 V nominal, 2.35 Ah, 4.20 V maximum charge, 1.59 A maximum charge current and 2.30 A maximum discharge. However its contacts are SCL, +, SDA (ID), −, not a documented three-wire pack thermistor. It uses I²C. The exact analog NTC curve and direct BQ24075 approval remain unverified. Older RRC1120 material uses different capacity/contact descriptions; do not merge generations. RRC1130 appeared in the same family search but was not selected or qualified. Stop this branch rather than introduce a smart-pack interface redesign.
  2. Inspired Energy search returned ND2037HD29, whose nominal operating voltage is 7.2 V. It is not a candidate for the present 1S architecture. No qualified three-wire 1S product was established by the bounded search. This is not a claim that the vendor has none.
No alternative stock/price or thermal-window closure is claimed, because neither alternative passed the interface gate. No additional families should be churned for this PCB revision without a scoped new sourcing decision.
Exact integration brief to main writer
Current revision: implement charging-deferred state
  1. Preserve existing default-off CE architecture, but distinguish default off from non-enableable while unqualified. Do not rely solely on firmware holding CHARGE_ENABLE low. For a build with this unqualified combination, establish a physical inhibit that cannot be overridden by host firmware (for example an omitted enable-path link/device or permanent disable configuration), after reviewing the exact charger pin requirements. Do not short CE against an enabled pull-down.
  2. Keep pack optional/absent for unrelated PCB work; vehicle and approved USB power/programming must operate without the pack. Do not use an arbitrary TS resistor as an installed-pack substitute or claim an absent sensor is qualified.
  3. Do not install/charge the GlobTek pack on the existing board. Bench discharge evaluation requires a separately approved charging method and explicit current/cutoff/temperature supervision; no external charger was qualified here.
  4. Label release status: backup charging DEFERRED, 14-day runtime UNVERIFIED, optional pack NOT REQUIRED for unrelated layout/programming work. This does not clear other fabrication blockers.
Single bounded path for a future charging-enabled revision
Use the existing GlobTek pack concept only if its exact supplied revision obtains authoritative thermistor MPN/R–T tolerances and charge/standby approval. Then select a documented adjustable/4.1-V charger and hardware thermal window; nominal +5 to +40°C is only a margin target, not a calculated resistor choice. All tolerance corners and hysteresis must remain within 0–45°C. Require battery-mounted sensing, open/short sensor inhibition and safe no-pack behavior, hardware default off independent of firmware, correct termination/timer, input/USB power budgeting, thermal dissipation and backfeed protection. A new PCB controller must have exact JLCPCB C-number plus assembly-stock evidence before selection. No such controller is selected by this report because thermistor data are the earlier blocking dependency.
Acceptance evidence required before enabling charge
  • Published manufacturer data tied to purchased revision for NTC curve and tolerances; supported pack charge/standby voltage/current policy.
  • Worst-case hot/cold cutoff calculation including sensor, charger/comparator, resistor tolerances and hysteresis; thermal lag/self-heating assessed.
  • Open/short NTC, pack removal, host reset/off and arbitrary host GPIO states tested. No-pack/open-NTC must not authorize charging.
  • Voltage/current/termination/timer verified over supply and temperature; cell temperature tested in the actual parked-cabin environment.
  • Low-cell radio peak and battery-path drop tested, system stops above pack-recommended discharge floor with suitable hysteresis.
  • Runtime measured with 15-minute LoRa plus bounded event/daily Wi-Fi. Existing 2.2-Ah budget ceilings are 6.55 mA full nominal or 4.58 mA with provisional 70% usable capacity over 336 h; these arithmetic ceilings do not prove 14 days.
Read-only verification and scope status
Read-only schematic inspection found Q6 drain on CHG_CE_N with U4 ~CE and R16, Q6 gate on CHG_EN_GATE with R56/R57, and Q6 source now on CHG_EN_SRC with Q9 drain. Q6's Role Details still describe its source as GND; that text is stale relative to current net membership, likely reflecting ongoing writer changes. This inspection is not a full review of the Q9 interlock and does not certify CE safety. No circuit edits or design-review issue writes were made.
  • Completed: read required files; bounded manufacturer/web/datasheet research; identify precise blockers; durable separate handoff; read-only current enable-net inspection.
  • Failed to establish: qualified rechargeable pack/charger solution with exact NTC data and conservative hardware window. Blocker: missing GlobTek thermistor characterization; alternatives did not establish required interface.
  • Unattempted intentionally: circuit/layout/spec edits, charger procurement substitution, resistor calculation from unknown NTC, physical qualification and purchase.
  • Warning: default-off firmware policy alone is not a release mechanism for an unqualified charging combination.
  • Info: research batch complete; overall backup integration and project release are not complete.
Datasheet-query handles: GlobTek dsq_7ed64abbadf598f9247f; RRC1120 dsq_926d8050a64361dc5e0b; Inspired Energy dsq_baa655e86cc43793f50e. URLs above are access links, not substitutes for validated claims.
  • Decision — 2026-10-22

  • Existing candidate — facts reused from Backup Battery Recommendation

  • New targeted datasheet check

  • Procurement evidence

  • Bounded alternative-family screening

  • Exact integration brief to main writer

  • Current revision: implement charging-deferred state

  • Single bounded path for a future charging-enabled revision

  • Acceptance evidence required before enabling charge

  • Read-only verification and scope status

  • Source access links