I’ll make the PCB placeholder a continuous annulus—keeping its center opening and mounting holes—and measure how far it must rise to clear J1. I’ll check the raised position against the cap, tray, and battery, and flag any mounting changes it requires rather than hiding collisions.
Updated the green placeholder to a continuous 55/30 mm annulus, retaining its mounting holes, and raised its underside 8 mm to z=11 mm, providing 0.5 mm nominal clearance above J1.
It is provisional, not fitted: the raised ring intersects the battery and no longer engages the cap supports or spring contacts. Everything else is unchanged; measurements and renders are in Continuous Ring Clearance Check.
The ring is now continuous and raised 8 mm, giving 0.5 mm clearance above J1, but it intersects the battery and is not a fitted assembly.
Preserved: 55 mm OD, 30 mm center opening, 1 mm thickness, and three mounting holes.
Existing support pins/hooks no longer engage; the spring contacts now have 8 mm gaps.
Raising it further cannot solve this inside the current cap: the battery and roof limits conflict by 0.75 mm, even before adding clearance.
Only the ring placeholder changed; everything else remains untouched. I recommend keeping this position provisional while checking a revised internal stack. Which direction would you like?
Superseded build status: The owner subsequently authorized provisional assumptions and the live55 mm ring. Four actual candidate assets and installed nodes now exist; see @enclosure-candidate-review for current models, renders and measured acceptance failures. The preflight findings below remain historical evidence, not the current no-CAD status.
Date: 2026-09-24. Incomplete — no enclosure CAD assets or model nodes authored. This is a preflight record, not a manufacturing release or a completed enclosure. The controlling Enclosure Design Brief was read in full, then reread after the dusty-factory correction. No schematic, component placement, routing, board rules, or board geometry was modified.
Environment correction acknowledged
The current requirement is indoor dusty factory, not simply dry. Subsequent geometry must retain SLA white engineering resin for base/cap/tray and translucent resin for the separate window; an overlapping/tortuous bayonet seam; minimized clearances within the requested 0.2–0.3 mm fit class; and a downward-facing labyrinth vent with no straight exterior-to-cavity path. No rain/washdown provisions or IP claim. These requirements are recorded, not implemented in geometry. Dust resistance, snap life and fit will require physical particulate/cycling/calibration tests.
Completed live inspection
Base PCB is circular, 50 mm diameter, centered at project (0,0), with no layout rotation or translation. Reported substrate thickness is 1.600 mm. PCB top is the mechanical z=0 datum; underside is z=-1.600 mm. Stackup additionally lists copper/mask/paste thicknesses; physical as-built thickness remains subject to fabrication confirmation.
Six 2.2 mm NPTHs are present. Four centers are (±15.556349, ±15.556349) mm, matching the specified 44 mm PCD at 45/135/225/315 degrees to readback precision. The other two resolve to (0,+13) and (0,-13) mm via positionX/positionY overrides, despite legacy E/W names and older vector positions. Do not use the obsolete (±13,0) vectors.
All 36 component placements were read. U1 is at effective (17.25,0) mm, rotated 270 degrees; its older vector position is overridden. Antenna end appears toward +X in the board render.
P1–P7 use the corrected Mill-Max identity and centers on nominal radius 20.5 mm. Their model nodes are absent in the returned live model list, as is U2's model. Rendered empty contact locations are not clearance evidence.
J1 (Molex 0470531000, SWD header) is at (-3.6625,16.0234) mm, top-side, rotation 0. Model-local translation is (-3.8,0,3) mm, rotation (90,0,0) degrees. The actual model is visibly a tall vertical header. Its mating direction is top-entry, perpendicular to the board.
J1 footprint pin centers are approximately (-3.6625,16.0234), (-6.2025,16.0234), (-8.7425,16.0234), and (-11.2825,16.0234) mm. Its local body/courtyard polygon was inspected rather than treating its placement origin as its body center.
The separate live ring project reports a 55 mm circular outline, not the brief's 52 mm OD. Its reported substrate is 0.930 mm with 0.035 mm copper on each side; this should not be mislabeled a confirmed thickness conflict with the nominal 1 mm brief.
The separate live charger project reports 26×16 mm board dimensions, substrate 1.510 mm, and component bounds extending to approximately x=+15.55 mm. Therefore the nominal PCB rectangle alone does not establish charger/harness clearance.
Build gates requiring resolution
1. Ring PCB / live J1 collision risk — blocks cap stack and assembly acceptance
Taking “PCB sits 6 mm above base floor” as underside seating on 6 mm bosses, and “ring PCB plane” as the intended contacting underside:
Table
Plane
Above base bottom
Project z
Base bottom
0
-11.6 mm
Base floor top
4
-7.6 mm
Sensor PCB underside
10
-1.6 mm
Sensor PCB top
11.6
0
Ring contacting underside
14.6
+3.0 mm
Ring top, brief 1 mm board
15.6
+4.0 mm
Battery bay
18–38.3
+6.4–26.7 mm
J1's four pin axes fall within the specified ring annulus (13≤r≤26 mm), and the tall header is visible in that area. A solid annular ring board at z=3–4 mm therefore has a serious collision concern; its central 26 mm hole does not clear these pin axes. Exact solid intersection and penetration depth are not verified. The attempted GLB measurement could not run because the sandbox neither received the binary attachment nor had network access.
Datasheet extraction initially misidentified DIM A as above-board height. That value was rejected: DIM A is the PC-tail dimension, not a safe clearance height. The source confirms table A=3.50, B=13.50, C=7.50 mm and the seating surface, but did not verify the extracted pin-tip/housing-height interpretations. Do not accept 3.50 mm as the header's above-board height.
Resolution needed: confirm an approved ring relief/geometry around J1, or another approved stack/connector solution. Moving J1, modifying either PCB, or raising the ring plane was not authorized. The separate live ring's 55 mm OD also needs reconciliation with the controlling 52 mm requirement before its mounting pattern can be used.
2. Magnet-cup flange and seating stack unknown — blocks finished magnetic base
The brief fixes magnet Ø20×3 and cup barrel Ø22×3.2 plus a press flange, but supplies neither flange OD/thickness nor its relationship to the magnet face and cup seating shoulder. No exact matching cup drawing was identified. Those dimensions govern the stepped pocket, retained press fit, and required 0.2 mm face projection. They cannot be safely invented from a generic cup product. Supply the chosen cup drawing/MPN or measured flange and axial-stack dimensions. Calibration-dependent interference remains PROVISIONAL even once nominal geometry is known.
3. Spring height evidence unresolved — blocks contact-force/travel and ≥0.5 mm clearance certification
The brief's 4.2 mm projection would require 1.2 mm compression to the derived 3 mm ring gap if it means free height above the sensor PCB. Search results for the exact live 0906-0 variant suggest a different initial height, but authoritative evidence retrieval failed, including evidence_location_invalid for two sources. No exact replacement height or permissible stroke is certified here. Resolve free versus working projection and exact selected-pin dimensions before declaring the stack valid. Missing models also prevent a rendered pin-clearance check.
A plain 3 mm tray under a 19 mm cylindrical battery stacks to 22 mm, exceeding the 20.3 mm bay by 1.7 mm before clearance. A recessed/windowed cradle could be designed, so this is not proof that every tray design is impossible. It does require a defined tray cross-section, retention, and extraction route.
The 71 mm tray cannot pass straight/flat through the 64.8 mm skirt opening, and a 28 mm wide tray cannot pass straight through the ring's 26 mm central opening. A tilt route or separate service opening may resolve this, but the ring mounting, bay-floor web, charger, and all service motions must be checked together. Do not claim daily tool-less replacement by silently requiring removal of M2 board screws. No extra hatch or PCB cutout was added without resolving the controlling assembly intent.
Dust/SLA details to carry into the resumed design
Select and document whether the requested 0.2–0.3 mm fit value is a per-side surface clearance or a total diametral clearance. Do not silently mix these conventions.
General ±0.15 mm tolerance on both mating dimensions can consume up to 0.30 mm of a total dimensional gap; nominal clearance alone does not guarantee free twist travel. A fit coupon and process calibration are mandatory.
Put a continuous overlapping barrier inward of the bayonet slots, so the slots do not bypass the dust seam. Verify the barrier throughout insertion, lock and release travel.
A downward-facing lower-wall labyrinth must have offset openings and intervening material, remain washable/drainable during SLA post-processing, and keep the machine-contact face and magnet stack functional. No enclosed resin traps; choose drain/vent passages at least 2 mm where process requirements apply.
Engineering-resin detent and ring-retention flexures need explicit root transitions, bounded strain, accessible release, and print/cycle qualification. “Translucent resin” alone does not identify a qualified snap material.
Preserve the 8 mm -Y harness notch; final JST placement remains PROVISIONAL.
Assembled height accounting must include the magnet's 0.2 mm projection; a cap reaching 41 mm above resin base bottom would make the physical extreme-to-extreme height 41.2 mm.
Assigned deliverables and verification status
Table
Item
Status
Specific result/blocker
Read controlling brief including dust correction
Completed
Both versions read in full; revised requirements recorded above
Live outline, datum, stack, six mounting holes
Completed
Readback evidence above
Component/model/connector inspection
Completed with limits
Live nodes, transforms, 2D J1 footprint and two board renders inspected; missing-model and dimensional limits disclosed
Fixed magnetic base Build123d asset/node
Unattempted
Cup flange/seating dimensions unresolved; no fabricated fit-critical dimensions
Twist-lock cap Build123d asset/node
Unattempted
Ring/J1 interference concern, ring geometry mismatch and service route unresolved
Removable battery tray Build123d asset/node
Unattempted
Coupled battery cross-section, capture and removal route unresolved
Separate translucent ring Build123d asset/node
Unattempted
Mating cap/window seat not established; isolated cosmetic torus would not meet snap-in deliverable
Base, cap, assembled-with-PCB and exploded renders
Unattempted
No accepted or candidate enclosure solids exist
PCB-only reference renders
Completed
Two actual-geometry views below
Exact connector mesh collision measurement
Failed
Binary asset unavailable in non-networked compute sandbox
The requested build is not complete. No model candidate was presented as printable, no SLA fit or snap life was qualified, and no IP performance was claimed. Geometry repair cycles used: zero.
Actual PCB reference renders
These views were generated and inspected; they do not show a completed enclosure. Pogo contacts and U2 lack model assets and are not rendered. Editor focus on J1 was attempted, but frontend acknowledgement timed out; browser presentation is not confirmed.
PCB isometric reference
PCB top reference
Environment correction acknowledged
Completed live inspection
Build gates requiring resolution
1. Ring PCB / live J1 collision risk — blocks cap stack and assembly acceptance
2. Magnet-cup flange and seating stack unknown — blocks finished magnetic base
3. Spring height evidence unresolved — blocks contact-force/travel and ≥0.5 mm clearance certification