Routing Recovery Report
Status
Bounded recovery pass: blocked. Placement was not changed. The pass committed scoped routing-rule changes and regenerated deterministic neckdowns, but the final board still has 43 airwire errors.
Fresh Starting State
- 49 airwire errors.
- 0 overlapping-copper errors.
- 0 floating-copper errors.
- 2 dangling-trace warnings, both previously identified protected USB-C breakout stubs.
- Four-layer 0.8 mm nominal stack retained.
- Preflight reported the intentional same-net microphone ground-pad merge/keepout condition, U4 EN2 and ~CE pin-in-keepout warnings, and five USB differential-pair pin-access warnings.
Rule Corrections Applied
Three scoped rulesets were added:
- Narrow control/data: 0.15 mm trace width, 0.15 mm minimum width, 0.09 mm clearance for I2C, charger control/status, microphone control, SWDIO, regulator configuration, LED, and residual flash nets.
- Compact power/switch: 0.20 mm trace width, 0.15 mm minimum width, 0.09 mm clearance for REG_LX1, REG_LX2, BATTERY, SYS, and VBUS_PROTECTED.
- USB continuation: 0.20 mm continuation width, 0.15 mm minimum width, 0.09 mm clearance for the six USB data nets. The protected connector breakout retains its explicit 0.25 mm authored copper and was not deleted or replaced.
The 0.09 mm clearance remains above the active 3.5 mil (0.0889 mm) board minimum.
Neckdowns
A deterministic neckdown refresh was required after the scoped rule changes. The tool generated 27 current-condition neckdowns and retained unaffected existing neckdowns; history shows only stale affected neckdown nodes were rewritten. The USB breakout itself was not regenerated.
Targeted Routing Attempts
No full-board autorouter was run in this bounded pass. Surgical attempts were made on:
- CHG_TIMER:
U4:TMR ↔ R5:P1
- REG_LX1:
U5:LX1 ↔ L1:P1
- REG_LX2:
U5:LX2 ↔ L1:P2
- I2C_SCL:
U1:P0.27 ↔ U6:SCL; U6:SCL ↔ R10:P2
- I2C_SDA:
U6:SDA ↔ R9:P2 (the remaining trunk is U1:P0.26 ↔ U6:SDA)
- USB_DP_MCU:
U1:D+ ↔ R32:P1
- USB_DM_MCU:
U1:D- ↔ R33:P1
- VBUS_PROTECTED:
U10:VBUS ↔ C23:P1
The local I2C_SCL attempt returned blocked-no-path. Each multilayer path reported as routed by the surgical router created a disconnected via/trace island in fresh DRC. Those fragments were deleted in batches; no floating copper from failed attempts remains.
Final Checks
- Airwires: 43 errors.
- Floating copper: 0 errors.
- Overlapping copper/traces: 0 errors.
- Invalid layers / stackup / protected intrusion / keepout blockers: 0 errors in the selected final DRC set.
- Dangling traces: 2 warnings, both protected USB breakout stubs (
Trace 1aea and Trace b206); they were deliberately retained.
- Preflight: still reports 9 warnings: intentional microphone same-net merge and microphone keepout, U4 EN2/~CE inside a keepout, and five USB differential-pair endpoint-access groups.
Remaining affected nets include GND, I2C_SCL, I2C_SDA, REG_LX1, REG_LX2, LED_BLUE_ANODE, LED_RED_GPIO, USB_DP_MCU, USB_DM_MCU, USB_DP_PROTECTED, USB_DM_PROTECTED, USB_DP_CONN, USB_DM_CONN, CHARGE_STATUS, USB_POWER_GOOD, PDM_CLK_3V3, 1V8 microphone-domain routing, SWDIO, REG_CFG1, REG_CFG2, BATTERY, SYS, VBUS_PROTECTED, MIC_WAKE_3V3, MIC_THSEL_3V3, FLASH_MISO, FLASH_B_HOLD, and CHG_TIMER.
Exact Fixed-Placement Blockers and Smallest Proposed Moves
The repeated hotspot failure is CHG_TIMER: U4:TMR ↔ R5:P1, with adjacent ground escapes at R5:P2 and the U4 EN2/~CE ground pins competing for the same corridor. The congestion engine still identifies U4/R5/R6/R31 around (-10.5, -4.8) mm.
Smallest practical placement correction for that corridor:
- Move R5 +0.8 mm in X (center from -8.0 to -7.2 mm).
- Move R6 +0.8 mm in X (center from -6.0 to -5.2 mm) at the same time, preserving the R5/R6 spacing and avoiding a different-net pad overlap.
Additional independent switch-node blocker:
REG_LX1: U5:LX1 ↔ L1:P1
REG_LX2: U5:LX2 ↔ L1:P2
- Proposed minimum: move L1 +0.5 mm in X toward U5 (center from -6.0 to -5.5 mm).
These moves were not applied. USB and I2C also remain blocked by the fixed-placement channel capacity; they should be retried only after the hotspot/switch-node corridor is opened, because repeated fixed-placement multilayer surgical attempts produced disconnected islands rather than valid copper.
Preservation Confirmation
- No component placement changed.
- Protected USB-C breakout copper was preserved and remains at its authored geometry.
- BLE antenna keepout remains present; no protected-intrusion DRC was reported.
- Microphone port/acoustic geometry was untouched; its same-net merged ground-pad warning remains intentionally distinguished from real blockers.
- All failed-attempt floating/dangling fragments were removed; only protected USB stubs remain dangling by design.
Live Continuation Pass — 2026-09-04
Result
Bounded pass remains blocked, with valid progress committed. Fresh final checks report 44 airwire errors, 0 floating-copper errors, 0 overlapping-copper/traces errors, and 2 dangling warnings. The two dangling groups are the protected USB-C breakout stubs (Trace 1aea and Trace b206), not stale unprotected copper, so they were retained.
Placement and Neckdown Recovery
- Exact L1/U5 geometry confirmed the prior L1 position at (-5.5, -6.0) mm had a real 0.598 mm body overlap in X.
- L1 was moved back -0.5 mm X to (-6.0, -6.0) mm, preserving rotation and layer. The body overlap, bounds, and keepout checks are now clear.
- One stale unprotected REG_LX1 segment (
Trace 7922) created by the old L1 position was deleted.
- Deterministic neckdowns were regenerated; 29 current neckdowns were generated. Protected USB breakout copper was not regenerated or replaced.
Routing Attempts
Targeted attempts were made on:
REG_LX1: L1:P1 ↔ U5:LX1
REG_LX2: L1:P2 ↔ U5:LX2
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM
I2C_SCL: U1:P0.27 ↔ U6:SCL
I2C_SDA: U1:P0.26 ↔ U6:SDA
LED_BLUE_ANODE: LED1:A_BLUE ↔ R23:P2
The targeted router reported routes, but each failed connection either preserved the original airwire or generated disconnected/floating multilayer fragments. All such fragments were removed in fresh DRC-guided batches.
One permitted autoroute cleanup pass was resumed. It applied 127 routing nodes but returned unrouteable; after removing its new unprotected dangling/floating CHG_ILIM fragments, total airwires improved from 45 to 44. I2C_SDA no longer appears in the residual airwire list. No further autoroute pass was attempted.
Exact Residual Nets and Logical Endpoints
The 44 airwires consist of 22 GND connectivity gaps plus these 22 non-GND connections:
I2C_SCL: remaining R10:P2 branch to the U1:P0.27/U6:SCL routed trunk.
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM.
REG_LX2: L1:P2 ↔ U5:LX2.
LED_BLUE_ANODE: LED1:A_BLUE ↔ R23:P2.
USB_DP_MCU: U1:D+ ↔ R32:P1.
USB_DP_PROTECTED: U10:6 (I/O1) ↔ R32:P2.
USB_DM_CONN: J1:DN1/DN2 breakout side ↔ U10:3 (I/O2); the reported exact unresolved pin is J1:DN2 ↔ U10:3.
USB_DM_PROTECTED: U10:4 (I/O2) ↔ R33:P2.
CHARGE_STATUS: R7:P2 branch to the U1:P0.29/U4:~CHG route.
USB_POWER_GOOD: R8:P2 ↔ U4:~PGOOD branch (U1:P0.30 is on the same net).
PDM_CLK_3V3: U1:P0.13 ↔ U8:A1.
USB_DP_CONN: J1:DP1/DP2 breakout side ↔ U10:1 (I/O1); the reported exact unresolved pin is J1:DP2 ↔ U10:1.
REG_LX1: L1:P1 ↔ U5:LX1.
SWDIO: U1:SWDIO ↔ J2:2.
REG_CFG1: R2:P1 ↔ U5:CFG1.
LED_RED_GPIO: U1:P0.06 ↔ R24:P1.
MIC_THSEL_3V3: U1:P0.15 ↔ U9:A1.
REG_CFG2: R3:P1 ↔ U5:CFG2.
FLASH_B_HOLD: U3:~HOLD/SIO3 ↔ R17:P2.
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR.
USB_DM_MCU: U1:D- ↔ R33:P1.
SYS: remaining branch between C4:P1 and the U4 OUT/U5 VIN-EN SYS network.
Final Preflight Anomalies
Fresh autoroute preflight reports 10 warnings:
- Intentional T5838 same-net merged GND pads.
- T5838 merged GND pin inside its acoustic keepout.
- U4 EN2 and ~CE pins inside the local keepout.
- Six blocked USB differential-pair endpoint groups: J1 connector pins, U10 connector-side pins, U10 protected-side pins, R32/R33 protected-side pins, R32/R33 MCU-side pins, and U1 D+/D- pins.
Single Smallest Next Corrective Action
The congestion engine still marks the U4/R5/R6/R31 corridor near (-10.5, -4.8) mm as unrouteable after the approved R5/R6 shifts and two genuine targeted/autoroute attempts. The next smallest placement correction is to move U4 by 0.5 mm in -X (center from -11.1 to -11.6 mm), preserving rotation and layer. This opens another 0.5 mm between U4 and R5/R6 for the TMR/ILIM and nearby ground escapes while remaining inside the circular board; re-run overlap/keepout checks immediately after the move.
USB differential endpoint-access anomalies are an independent remaining blocker and must be handled after the charger hotspot is reopened; the protected ~90-ohm connector breakout itself must remain unchanged.
Preservation Confirmation
- Protected ~90-ohm USB-C breakout preserved exactly; its two protected dangling stub groups remain.
- BLE antenna all-layer keepout preserved; final selected DRC reports no protected intrusion or keepout error.
- T5838 acoustic keepout preserved; the intentional same-net microphone GND geometry remains distinguished from real violations.
- L1, R5, and R6 rotations/layers preserved; only the explicitly authorized L1 reversal was made in this pass.
- Neckdowns refreshed to 29 current deterministic neckdowns; protected USB copper was not touched.
U4 Minimum-Correction Validation — 2026-09-04
Placement Result
The approved U4 move was applied exactly: U4 X -11.1 → -11.6 mm, with Y = -4.5 mm, rotation, and Top side preserved. Bounds and keepout checks remained clear, but exact geometry and placement feedback found a real C3 ↔ U4 overlap. C3 spans x = -15.625…-13.175 mm; U4 at -11.6 mm spans x = -13.5…-9.7 mm, producing approximately 0.325 mm X overlap. The move also made charger-area copper stale and initially produced 26 overlapping-copper errors.
All newly stale, unprotected charger traces/vias were deleted in batches. Because the approved placement was physically invalid, U4 was restored to (-11.1, -4.5) mm; this removed the C3/U4 overlap while preserving U4 rotation and side. No other component was moved.
Neckdowns and Targeted Routing
- Deterministic neckdowns were refreshed after both the attempted move and the restoration; the final board has 29 generated neckdowns.
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR was attempted at 0.15 mm. The router reported a multilayer route, but fresh DRC found floating copper; the fragment was removed.
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM was attempted at 0.15 mm. It did not reduce the airwire count and produced a floating multilayer fragment; the fragment was removed.
- Autoroute preflight remained unsuitable because it reports blocked USB differential-pair endpoints plus the known microphone/U4 keepout warnings. No cleanup autoroute pass was run.
Fresh Final State
- 44 airwire errors: 20 GND connectivity gaps and 24 non-GND gaps.
- 0 floating-copper, overlapping-copper, invalid-layer, protected-intrusion, component-body-overlap, bounds, or keepout blockers in the final selected DRC set.
- 2 dangling warnings, both protected USB breakout handoff stubs:
Trace 1aea and Trace b206.
The 24 non-GND residual connections are:
I2C_SCL: R10:P2 branch ↔ U1:P0.27/U6:SCL trunk.
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM.
REG_LX2: L1:P2 ↔ U5:LX2.
LED_BLUE_ANODE: LED1:A_BLUE ↔ R23:P2.
USB_DP_MCU: U1:D+ ↔ R32:P1.
USB_DP_PROTECTED: U10:6 ↔ R32:P2.
USB_DM_CONN: J1:DN2 breakout side ↔ U10:3.
USB_DM_PROTECTED: U10:4 ↔ R33:P2.
CHARGE_STATUS: R7:P2 branch ↔ U1:P0.29/U4:~CHG network.
USB_POWER_GOOD: R8:P2 branch ↔ U1:P0.30/U4:~PGOOD network.
PDM_CLK_3V3: U1:P0.13 ↔ U8:A1.
USB_DP_CONN: J1:DP2 breakout side ↔ U10:1.
REG_LX1: L1:P1 ↔ U5:LX1.
SWDIO: U1:SWDIO ↔ J2:2.
REG_CFG1: R2:P1 ↔ U5:CFG1.
LED_RED_GPIO: U1:P0.06 ↔ R24:P1.
MIC_THSEL_3V3: U1:P0.15 ↔ U9:A1.
USB_CURRENT_SELECT: U4:EN1 branch ↔ U1:P0.31/R31:P1 network.
REG_CFG2: R3:P1 ↔ U5:CFG2.
FLASH_B_HOLD: U3:~HOLD/SIO3 ↔ R17:P2.
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR.
USB_DM_MCU: U1:D- ↔ R33:P1.
SYS: residual U4 OUT ↔ C4:P1/U5 VIN-EN SYS-network branch.
VBUS_PROTECTED: residual U4:IN ↔ F1:P2/D1:1/U10:VBUS/U1:VBUS/C3:P1/C23:P1 network branch.
Single Smallest Next Corrective Action
Move C3 by -0.5 mm in X, from (-14.4, -4.5) to (-14.9, -4.5) mm, preserving rotation and side. This creates enough clearance for the already approved U4 -0.5 mm X correction to be reapplied without the measured C3/U4 overlap; the circular-board boundary still has clearance at C3's Y coordinate. After that enabling move, reapply U4 to -11.6 mm X, refresh its neckdowns, and retry the TMR/ILIM charger corridor.
Preservation Confirmation
- Protected ~90-ohm USB-C breakout was not deleted or regenerated.
- Both protected USB dangling handoff stubs remain intact.
- BLE antenna all-layer keepout and T5838 acoustic keepout remain intact; no protected-intrusion or keepout blocker was reported.
- All failed-route fragments from this pass were removed; only DRC-clean existing copper and protected structures remain.
C3 Corridor Pass — 2026-09-04
Placement Validation
- Applied the explicitly approved C3 move from (-14.4, -4.5) mm to (-14.9, -4.5) mm, preserving Top side and 0° rotation.
- Fresh focused checks found 0 C3/U4 body overlaps, 0 out-of-bounds errors, 0 keepout violations, and 0 pad-access errors.
- No other component was moved.
Cleanup and Neckdowns
- The two pre-existing dangling groups remained
Trace 1aea and Trace b206; these are the protected USB-C breakout handoff stubs and were deliberately retained.
- Failed targeted-route floating and newly dangling fragments were deleted in DRC-guided batches.
- Deterministic fine-pitch neckdowns were refreshed after cleanup; 29 neckdowns were generated. Protected USB breakout copper was not regenerated or replaced.
Routing Result and Attempts
- Valid progress committed:
VBUS_PROTECTED: C3:P1 ↔ U4:IN routed successfully at 0.20 mm and its previous airwire cleared.
- Bounded surgical attempts on
CHG_TIMER, CHG_ILIM, REG_LX1, REG_LX2, I2C_SCL, I2C_SDA, and REG_CFG1 either returned blocked-no-path or created disconnected/floating multilayer islands. All invalid fragments were removed.
- Existing unprotected partial fragments on CHG_TIMER and CHG_ILIM were removed and both nets were retried cleanly pad-to-pad; the same disconnected-island failure persisted.
- No autoroute pass was run because fresh preflight remained unsuitable: six USB differential endpoint groups are reported unrouteable, alongside the intentional microphone geometry and U4 EN2/~CE keepout warnings.
Fresh Final Checks
- 44 airwire errors.
- 0 non-airwire blocking DRC errors in the selected complete layout set: no floating copper, overlapping copper/traces, invalid layers, stackup error, protected intrusion, under-connected via, body overlap, bounds, pad-access, edge-placement, or keepout error.
- 2 dangling warnings, both protected USB breakout stubs (
Trace 1aea, Trace b206).
- The successful VBUS_PROTECTED connection removed that residual; a new exact GND residual is
R2:P2 ↔ R1:P2.
The critical logical residual endpoints remain:
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR.
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM.
REG_LX1: L1:P1 ↔ U5:LX1.
REG_LX2: L1:P2 ↔ U5:LX2.
I2C_SCL: R10:P2 ↔ routed U1:P0.27/U6:SCL trunk.
- USB continuation:
U1:D+ ↔ R32:P1, U1:D- ↔ R33:P1, R32:P2 ↔ U10:6, R33:P2 ↔ U10:4, J1:DP2 ↔ U10:1, and J1:DN2 ↔ U10:3.
- Other exact pin residuals still include
U1:SWDIO ↔ J2:2, U1:P0.13 ↔ U8:A1, U1:P0.15 ↔ U9:A1, R3:P1 ↔ U5:CFG2, U3:~HOLD/SIO3 ↔ R17:P2, R7:P2 ↔ CHARGE_STATUS trunk, R8:P2 ↔ U4:~PGOOD, and U4:EN1 ↔ USB_CURRENT_SELECT trunk.
- Remaining multi-node gaps are on GND and SYS.
Single Smallest Next Corrective Action
Now that C3 is at -14.9 mm and no longer blocks the left side of U4, reapply the previously documented U4 -0.5 mm X move, from (-11.1, -4.5) mm to (-11.6, -4.5) mm, preserving side and rotation. Exact body geometry now leaves approximately 0.175 mm between C3 and U4 instead of overlapping; validate clearance immediately after the move, then reroute TMR/ILIM before the other residuals.
Preservation Confirmation
- Protected ~90-ohm USB-C breakout preserved exactly.
- BLE antenna all-layer keepout preserved; no protected-intrusion or keepout error.
- T5838 acoustic keepout and intentional merged same-net GND-pad geometry preserved.
- Locked/deterministic neckdowns preserved and refreshed to 29 current nodes.
U4 Shift and Clean Routing Pass — 2026-09-04
Placement and Validation
- Applied the approved U4 move exactly: (-11.1, -4.5) → (-11.6, -4.5) mm, preserving 180° rotation and Top side.
- With C3 already at (-14.9, -4.5) mm, focused validation found 0 U4/C3 or U4/R5/R6/R31 body overlaps, 0 bounds errors, 0 keepout errors, and 0 pad-access DRC errors.
- The move initially exposed 14 overlapping-copper errors and one floating group from old U4-position-dependent routing. All affected unprotected traces/vias were batch-deleted; the protected USB breakout and locked neckdowns were excluded.
- Deterministic neckdowns were refreshed; the tool generated 28 current neckdowns after the move while preserving unaffected locked neckdown copper.
Valid Routing Progress
BATTERY: the U4 BAT branch to C5:P1 was restored successfully.
VBUS_PROTECTED: U4:IN ↔ C3:P1 was restored successfully after the placement shift.
CHG_ISET: R4:P1 ↔ U4:ISET routed successfully at 0.15 mm and cleared its airwire.
Bounded Attempts and Cleanup
- Fresh pad-to-pad attempts on
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR and USB_CURRENT_SELECT: R31:P1 ↔ U4:EN1 returned blocked-no-path after stale U4-position-dependent partial traces were removed.
- Attempts on
CHG_ILIM, SYS, REG_LX1, REG_LX2, I2C_SCL, I2C_SDA, REG_CFG1, REG_CFG2, FLASH_B_HOLD, CHARGE_STATUS, and related U4/GND branches either returned no path or generated disconnected multilayer islands. Every new floating group was removed in DRC-guided batches.
- One cleanup autoroute was attempted after the U4 TMR/PGOOD pin-access preflight warnings disappeared. The existing job remained paused because preflight returned
PLACEMENT_GENERIC: Board fully placed; no autorouted copper was added.
Fresh Final State
- 45 airwire errors: 21 GND connectivity gaps and 24 non-GND gaps.
- 0 non-airwire blocking DRC errors in the selected complete set: no floating copper, overlapping copper/traces, invalid layers, protected intrusions, under-connected vias, stackup errors, trace-corner errors, body overlaps, bounds, pad-access, or keepout errors.
- 2 dangling warnings, both intentional protected USB handoff stubs:
Trace 1aea and Trace b206.
- Fresh autoroute preflight now has 9 warnings: the intentional microphone same-net/keepout conditions, U4
~CE in its local keepout, and six blocked USB differential endpoint groups. The previous U4 TMR and ~PGOOD unrouteable-pin warnings are cleared.
The 24 non-GND residual connections are:
I2C_SCL: R10:P2 branch ↔ U1:P0.27/U6:SCL network.
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM partial-route groups.
REG_LX2: L1:P2 ↔ U5:LX2.
LED_BLUE_ANODE: LED1:A_BLUE ↔ R23:P2.
USB_DP_MCU: U1:D+ ↔ R32:P1.
USB_DP_PROTECTED: R32:P2 ↔ U10:I/O1.
USB_DM_CONN: J1:DN2 breakout side ↔ U10:I/O2.
USB_DM_PROTECTED: R33:P2 ↔ U10:I/O2.
CHARGE_STATUS: R7:P2 branch ↔ U1/U4 ~CHG network.
USB_POWER_GOOD: R8:P2 ↔ U4:~PGOOD branch.
PDM_CLK_3V3: U1:P0.13 ↔ U8:A1.
USB_DP_CONN: J1:DP2 breakout side ↔ U10:I/O1.
REG_LX1: L1:P1 ↔ U5:LX1.
SWDIO: U1:SWDIO ↔ J2:2.
I2C_SDA: remaining partial-route gap on the U1:P0.26/U6:SDA/R9:P2 network.
LED_RED_GPIO: U1:P0.06 ↔ R24:P1.
MIC_THSEL_3V3: U1:P0.15 ↔ U9:A1.
18–19. USB_CURRENT_SELECT: two gaps in the U4:EN1/U1:P0.31/R31:P1 three-node network.
REG_CFG2: R3:P1 ↔ U5:CFG2.
FLASH_B_HOLD: U3:~HOLD/SIO3 ↔ R17:P2.
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR.
- Remaining storage/control partial-route gap reported as
Trace a8bf ↔ terminal 6b86e9af.
SYS: remaining U4:OUT ↔ C4:P1/U5 VIN-EN network branch.
Single Smallest Next Corrective Action
The approved U4 shift is geometrically valid and cleared the charger pin-access preflight warnings, but the fresh router still cannot cross the lower charger corridor. The smallest next placement correction is to move R31 by -0.8 mm in Y, from (-11.0, -9.0) to (-11.0, -9.8) mm, preserving side and rotation. This opens the channel directly below U4's bottom-edge TMR, ISET, and ITERM escapes while staying inside the circular board; validate R31 bounds/overlap immediately, then reroute CHG_TIMER and USB_CURRENT_SELECT before other nets.
Preservation Confirmation
- Protected ~90-ohm USB-C breakout preserved exactly; no protected copper was deleted or regenerated.
- BLE antenna all-layer keepout preserved; no protected-intrusion or keepout blocker was reported.
- T5838 acoustic keepout and intentional merged same-net GND-pad geometry preserved.
- All newly introduced floating/dangling fragments were removed; only the two protected USB handoff stubs remain dangling.
R31 Corridor Validation Pass — 2026-09-04
Placement Result
- Applied the approved R31 move from (-11.0, -9.0) to (-11.0, -9.8) mm, preserving Top side and rotation.
- Bounds and keepouts remained clear, but exact geometry and autoroute preflight found a real different-net pad overlap: R31:P2 (GND) overlaps R8:P1 (3V3). The overlap is about 0.06 mm in X and 0.14 mm in Y, and fresh DRC reported two overlapping-copper errors from the same physical conflict.
- Because this is a manufacturing-blocking 3V3-to-GND short, R31 was restored to the last clean position (-11.0, -9.0) mm. The overlap and body-overlap reports then cleared.
Cleanup, Neckdowns, and Routing Attempts
- Removed only unprotected stale copper detached during the temporary R31 move; retained
Trace 1aea and Trace b206, the protected USB handoff stubs.
- Regenerated 29 deterministic neckdowns after cleanup; the protected USB breakout was not regenerated or altered.
CHG_ISET: R4:P1 ↔ U4:ISET was restored successfully at 0.15 mm after stale cleanup.
- Bounded targeted attempts on
CHG_TIMER, CHG_ILIM, REG_LX1, REG_LX2, I2C_SCL, and I2C_SDA either returned blocked-no-path or created floating multilayer islands. Every failed-route fragment was deleted in DRC-guided batches.
- No autoroute pass was run: preflight was not suitable while the R31/R8 short existed, and after restoration it still reports the six known USB differential endpoint groups plus the intentional microphone and U4
~CE keepout warnings.
Fresh Final State
- 45 airwire errors.
- 0 non-airwire blocking DRC errors in the selected complete set: no floating copper, overlapping copper/traces, invalid layers, protected intrusions, under-connected vias, stackup errors, trace-corner errors, body overlaps, bounds, pad-access, or keepout errors.
- 2 dangling warnings, both protected USB breakout stubs (
Trace 1aea, Trace b206).
- Critical residual endpoints remain
R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR, R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM, L1:P1 ↔ U5:LX1, L1:P2 ↔ U5:LX2, R10:P2 ↔ U6:SCL/U1:P0.27, the six USB continuation pairs, R31:P1 ↔ U4:EN1/U1:P0.31, and the previously listed GND/power/storage/control gaps.
Single Smallest Next Corrective Action
Approve an additional R31 -0.2 mm X correction while applying the -0.8 mm Y corridor move, placing R31 at (-11.2, -9.8) mm with rotation and side unchanged. The extra 0.2 mm left shift creates approximately 0.14 mm edge-to-edge pad separation from R8:P1, exceeding the active 0.09 mm minimum clearance, while retaining the intended downward corridor opening.
Preservation Confirmation
- Protected ~90-ohm USB-C breakout preserved exactly.
- BLE antenna all-layer keepout and T5838 acoustic keepout preserved; no protected-intrusion or keepout DRC blocker was reported.
- Deterministic neckdowns remain present after the 29-neckdown refresh.
- Final placement is restored to the DRC-clean pre-pass state for R31; no invalid placement was left committed.
Live Routing Recovery — 2026-09-10
Scope Status
- Airwire mapping: completed. The live 46-airwire state was mapped by PCB net UID, component UID, and pad UID.
- Conservative stale-copper cleanup: completed. Of 203 reported stale copper nodes in 47 routing-state groups, 199 unprotected nodes were deleted in one batch; one newly exposed unprotected VBUS_PROTECTED trace was then deleted. Four protected USB breakout nodes were explicitly skipped by the deletion engine and retained.
- Routing: partially completed / placement-blocked. Cleanup reduced the board from 46 to 45 airwires. No targeted route attempted in this pass could be committed without creating an airwire/floating-copper error or returning blocked-no-path. The existing full-board job remained paused after preflight returned the known routing warnings plus
PLACEMENT_GENERIC: Board fully placed.
- R31 corridor: completed as a validation/reversal. At (-11.4, -9.8) mm it had no overlap, but
R31:P1 ↔ U4:EN1 failed in both directions and the corridor produced no routing improvement. R31 was therefore restored to the documented clean baseline (-11.0, -9.0) mm; rotation and Top side were preserved.
- Final verification: completed. Fresh routing-state and full Design Rule Checks were run after the R31 restoration.
Exact Progress
- Starting airwires: 46.
- Final airwires: 45.
- Net improvement: 1 airwire.
- Starting stale copper: 203 nodes / 47 routing-state groups / 44 DRC warnings.
- Final redundant copper: 4 nodes in 2 DRC warning groups (
Trace 196e, 3 nodes; Trace b206, 1 node). All four were positively identified by the mutation engine as protected generated USB breakout copper and were not deleted.
- Final blocking DRC: 45 airwire errors only.
- Final non-airwire blocking DRC: 0. The fresh full DRC returned no overlapping copper/traces, floating copper, keepout, protected-intrusion, body-overlap, outside-board, or invalid-layer errors.
- Final DRC warnings: 2 redundant-trace warnings, both protected USB handoff groups above.
Routing Attempts in This Pass
All attempts were bounded and left no failed-route copper:
USB_DP_CONN: protected Trace b206 handoff ↔ U10:I/O1, attempted at 0.20 mm and 0.15 mm; rejected because the result would add checked airwire errors.
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM, attempted at 0.20 mm and 0.15 mm; rejected with airwire/floating-copper errors.
REG_LX2: U5:LX2 ↔ L1:P2, attempted at 0.25 mm and 0.20 mm; blocked-no-path.
REG_LX1: U5:LX1 ↔ L1:P1, attempted in both directions at 0.20 mm; blocked-no-path.
REG_CFG1: U5:CFG1 ↔ R2:P1, attempted in both directions at 0.15 mm; blocked-no-path.
REG_CFG2: U5:CFG2 ↔ R3:P1, attempted in both directions at 0.15 mm; blocked-no-path.
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR, attempted in both directions at 0.15 mm; blocked-no-path.
USB_CURRENT_SELECT: R31:P1 ↔ U4:EN1, attempted in both directions at 0.15 mm; rejected with airwire/floating-copper errors.
SWDIO: U1:SWDIO ↔ J2:2, attempted in both directions at 0.15 mm; blocked or rejected with airwire/floating-copper errors.
QSTRT/GND: U6:QSTRT ↔ U6:GND, attempted in both directions at 0.15 mm; blocked-no-path.
PDM_CLK_3V3: U1:P0.13 ↔ U8:A1, attempted in both directions at 0.15 mm; blocked or rejected with airwire/floating-copper errors.
Exact 25 Non-GND Residual Connections
I2C_SCL: R10:P2 ↔ Trace 246a (the routed U6:SCL / U1:P0.27 trunk).
CHG_ILIM: R6:P1 ↔ U4:ILIM.
REG_LX2: U5:LX2 ↔ L1:P2.
LED_BLUE_ANODE: LED1:A_BLUE ↔ R23:P2.
USB_DP_MCU: U1:D+ ↔ R32:P1.
USB_DP_PROTECTED: R32:P2 ↔ U10:I/O1 protected-side terminal (U10 pin 6 in the existing report mapping).
USB_DM_CONN: J1:DN2 protected-breakout side ↔ U10:I/O2 connector-side terminal (U10 pin 3).
USB_DM_PROTECTED: U10:I/O2 protected-side terminal (U10 pin 4) ↔ R33:P2.
CHARGE_STATUS: R7:P2 ↔ Trace c829 (the U4:~CHG / U1:P0.29 trunk).
USB_POWER_GOOD: R8:P2 ↔ U4:~PGOOD (U1:P0.30 is on the same logical net).
PDM_CLK_3V3: U1:P0.13 ↔ U8:A1.
USB_DP_CONN: J1:DP2 protected-breakout side ↔ U10:I/O1 connector-side terminal (U10 pin 1).
REG_LX1: U5:LX1 ↔ L1:P1.
3V3: Trace 37c1 ↔ Trace b6df routed groups.
SWDIO: U1:SWDIO ↔ J2:2.
REG_CFG1: U5:CFG1 ↔ R2:P1.
LED_RED_GPIO: R24:P1 ↔ U1:P0.06.
MIC_THSEL_3V3: U1:P0.15 ↔ U9:A1.
USB_CURRENT_SELECT: R31:P1 ↔ U4:EN1.
USB_CURRENT_SELECT: U1:P0.31 ↔ U4:EN1.
REG_CFG2: R3:P1 ↔ U5:CFG2.
FLASH_B_HOLD: U3:~HOLD/SIO3 ↔ R17:P2.
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR.
USB_DM_MCU: U1:D- ↔ R33:P1.
SYS: C4:P1 ↔ U4:OUT (remaining branch of the U4 OUT/U5 VIN-EN SYS network).
Exact 20 GND Residual Connections
R29:P2 ↔ C18:P2.
U6:QSTRT ↔ U6:GND.
U6:QSTRT ↔ Trace be1c.
R3:P2 ↔ D1:1.
C5:P2 ↔ C23:P2.
R29:P2 ↔ U1:GND (pad e69d6144).
U1:GND pad 59fdb6b8 ↔ U1:GND pad f673cc42.
- GND fill ↔
U1:GND pad 59fdb6b8.
C21:P2 ↔ U1:GND pad 25af59c6.
U3:EP ↔ C11:P2.
Trace a5da ↔ C6:P2.
Q3:E ↔ C9:P2.
U1:GND pad e69d6144 ↔ SW1 GND neckdown 17.
C18:P2 ↔ C23:P2.
J3:2 ↔ C15:P2.
- U5 GND neckdown 22 ↔ U6 GND neckdown 1.
- Q1 GND neckdown 20 ↔
Q2:E.
C22:P2 ↔ C20:P2.
C19:P2 ↔ C20:P2.
C14:P2 ↔ C20:P2.
Fresh Autoroute Preflight Blockers
The final preflight state remains unsuitable for a blind full-board pass:
- Intentional MK1 same-net overlapping GND pads and microphone GND pin inside the acoustic keepout.
U4:~CE inside its local keepout.
- Six unrouteable USB differential endpoint groups: J1 DP2/DN2, U10 connector-side pair, U10 protected-side pair, R32/R33 protected side, R32/R33 MCU side, and U1 D+/D-.
- Resuming the existing full-board job returned
PLACEMENT_GENERIC: Board fully placed; no autorouted copper was added.
Minimum Coherent Placement Rework Required
Do not continue with 0.2–0.8 mm blind nudges. The next pass needs coherent functional-cluster changes:
- USB cluster first — minimum single-component correction: rotate U10 by 180° in place at (0.0, -8.3) mm on Bottom. The current connector-side DP/DM pads are mirrored relative to the protected breakout handoff ends, forcing a crossover directly at U10. A 180° in-place rotation puts the connector-side pair toward J1 and the protected-side pair toward R32/R33 without altering the protected J1 breakout. This requires deleting only U10-position-dependent unprotected routing, regenerating U10 neckdowns if needed, and validating VBUS/GND before rerouting the six USB gaps.
- Charger support cluster if TMR/ILIM/EN1 remain the priority: reflow
R5, R6, R7, R8, R31 around fixed U4 rather than moving them individually. Proposed trial centers are R7 (-15.0,-3.75), R6 (-15.0,-5.5), R5 (-12.0,-7.2), R31 (-9.7,-2.0), and R8 (-9.7,-0.9) mm; rotate R6 and R8 by 180° so their signal pads face U4. These are planning coordinates and must receive a focused bounds/pad-clearance/body-overlap check before routing.
- Regulator cluster after charger/USB: move
L1 to the right side of U5, where U5's LX1/LX2 pads actually exit, and reflow the displaced support parts as one cluster. Proposed trial centers: L1 (0.9,-6.0), C2 (4.3,-6.0), R11 (3.8,-7.3) on Bottom, R2 (-5.2,-5.8) rotated 180°, and R3 (-5.2,-7.0) rotated 180°. Keep U5 and the already-routed CFG3/R1 branch fixed for the first trial.
No part of these broader cluster proposals was applied in this pass.
Preservation Confirmation
- The protected 90-ohm USB-C breakout is intact; the cleanup tool explicitly skipped its four protected nodes.
- BLE antenna all-layer keepout and microphone acoustic/ground keepout remain intact.
- Generated neckdowns were not bulk-deleted; only DRC-confirmed unprotected stale trace/via nodes were removed.
- Fresh full DRC reports zero protected-intrusion, keepout, overlapping-copper/traces, floating-copper, invalid-layer, body-overlap, or outside-board errors.
Charger Reflow and Routing Pass — 2026-09-10
Scope Results
- Charger placement reflow: completed. Fixed
U4 remained at (-11.6,-4.5) mm, Top, 180°. Final support placement is R6 (-13.8,-7.0) mm, 180°; R5 (-11.5,-8.0) mm, 0°; R4 (-9.8,-7.0) mm, 0°; R7 (-15.3,-0.2) mm, 0°; R8 (-8.0,-0.9) mm, 180°; and R31 (-8.0,-4.5) mm, 0°.
- Valid charger routes: completed for two nets.
CHG_ILIM: U4:ILIM ↔ R6:P1 and CHG_ISET: U4:ISET ↔ R4:P1 are routed on Top at 0.15 mm. R31:P2 is connected to C5:P2 on GND; the local R4/R5 GND copper was also routed without DRC errors.
- Stale/redundant copper cleanup: completed. Removed DRC-confirmed unprotected groups on
USB_POWER_GOOD, 3V3, GND, and charger nets. Protected USB groups Trace 196e and Trace b206 were retained.
- Verification: completed. Fresh selected DRC reports no overlapping copper, floating copper, protected intrusion, component overlap, pad-access, keepout, or board-bound errors. Remaining DRC warnings are the two protected USB redundant-handoff groups only.
Recovery and Safety Notes
- A 12-segment manual-route trial for
CHG_TIMER, CHG_ILIM, and USB_CURRENT_SELECT produced nine cross-net copper errors. The batch was removed; an accidental deletion of one pre-existing CHG_ISET segment was atomically reverted through project history, then only the 12 trial nodes were deleted. The final CHG_ISET route was rebuilt successfully.
- Moving
R31 to (-8.0,-4.5) mm eliminated its prior router keepout warnings and cleared tested FLASH/BATTERY-side copper conflicts.
- Autoroute preflight improved from 11 to 9 warnings. The R31 pin-in-keepout warnings are gone; remaining warnings are the intentional microphone geometry,
U4:~CE keepout condition, and six USB differential endpoint groups.
Fresh Residual State
- 52 airwires remain.
CHG_ILIM and CHG_ISET no longer appear in the residual list.
- Charger/control residuals still include
CHG_TIMER: R5:P1 ↔ U4:TMR, two USB_CURRENT_SELECT branches, CHARGE_STATUS: R7:P2 ↔ existing U4/U1 trunk, two USB_POWER_GOOD branches, 3V3 pull-up connections for R7/R8, and remaining GND-network gaps.
CHG_TIMER remained blocked after a pin-aligned placement rework and two genuine deterministic retries. USB_CURRENT_SELECT, CHARGE_STATUS, and USB_POWER_GOOD likewise remained blocked or were rejected because proposed routes created checked airwire/floating-copper errors. No failed-route copper remains.
- Full-board autorouting remains blocked primarily by the independent U10 duplicate
I/O1/I/O2 terminal definition and the six USB differential endpoint-access groups. The protected connector breakout is unchanged.
U10 Repair and Full-Board Routing Attempt — 2026-09-10
Scope Results
- U10 terminal ambiguity: completed. Replaced the UMW USBLC6-2SC6 instance, whose duplicate
I/O1 and I/O2 names made package-terminal routing ambiguous, with the STMicroelectronics USBLC6-2SC6 library instance (part UID 28716368-4362-4e14-9821-eabfb262908d). The ST datasheet pinout was verified as 1/6 = I/O1, 3/4 = I/O2, 2 = GND, and 5 = VBUS.
- U10 logical connectivity: completed. Final mapping is
1 → USB_DP_CONN, 6 → USB_DP_PROTECTED, 3 → USB_DM_CONN, 4 → USB_DM_PROTECTED, VBUS → VBUS_PROTECTED, and GND → GND.
- U10 placement: completed. Final position is
(0.0,-8.7) mm, Bottom, 270°. This preserves the original channel orientation and clears the R9/R10/R11 row. One stale unprotected old-footprint VBUS segment (Trace af0e) was removed after it shorted replacement pad 3.
- Protected USB breakout preservation: completed.
Trace 196e and Trace b206 remain unchanged. A provisional six-node USB via handoff was rejected after DRC exposed crossed net assignments and a via collision; all six provisional nodes were removed, returning to the clean protected-stub state.
- Full-board autoroute: attempted, unrouteable. A stale paused job was cancelled and a fresh job applied 108 routing nodes. The router returned
unrouteable, primarily because all six USB differential endpoint groups were blocked under the current placement/rules. After deleting three new unprotected redundant route groups, the valid committed autoroute work reduced the board from 52 to 42 airwires.
- Final verification: completed. Fresh selected ERC/DRC reports 0 non-airwire blocking errors: no overlapping/floating copper, invalid layers, protected intrusion, keepout, pad-access, component-overlap, outside-board, floating-pin, pin-conflict, power-pin, single-pin-net, or undriven-net findings.
Final Residual State
- 42 airwires remain: 22 GND-network gaps and 20 non-GND gaps.
- The 20 non-GND residuals are
REG_LX2, LED_BLUE_ANODE, USB_DP_MCU, USB_DP_PROTECTED, USB_DM_CONN, USB_DM_PROTECTED, MIC_WAKE_1V8, PDM_CLK_3V3, USB_DP_CONN, REG_LX1, one 3V3 branch to U9, SWDIO, PDM_DATA_3V3, MIC_THSEL_3V3, two USB_CURRENT_SELECT branches, REG_CFG2, FLASH_B_HOLD, USB_DM_MCU, and SYS.
- Five redundant groups remain reported: the two protected USB handoff groups, a pre-existing VBUS_PROTECTED group (
Trace 2353), and two pre-existing single-node groups (Trace 55a7, Trace 80b6). No newly generated unprotected redundant group from this autoroute pass remains.
Blocking Evidence
Fresh autoroute preflight still reports nine warnings: intentional MK1 merged-ground/keepout conditions, U4:~CE in its local keepout, and six unrouteable USB differential endpoint groups at J1, U10 connector side, U10 protected side, R32/R33 protected side, R32/R33 MCU side, and U1 D+/D-. The completed U10 replacement removes logical terminal ambiguity, but the physical differential-pair access remains blocked; further blind autoroute passes are not expected to improve the board.
Preservation Confirmation
- Accepted charger reflow and valid
CHG_ILIM, CHG_ISET, and charger-local GND routing were preserved.
- BLE antenna and microphone acoustic keepouts were preserved.
- Protected connector breakout copper was not deleted or regenerated.
- Final board state is electrically and geometrically clean apart from the explicitly reported 42 airwires and residual redundant-copper warnings.